The Penalty by Lynn MontaganoMy rating: 4 of 5 stars
⚽️ He’s a world-class goalie with secrets. She’s a woman who refuses to let guilt define her. When they meet, danger and desire collide.
🔥 Star goalie meets guilt-haunted woman = intense chemistry, deep secrets, and a romance that scores when it counts. Emotionally rich and totally binge-worthy!
Tropes
- Sports Romance
- Second Chance / Complicated Past
- Grumpy-Sunshine Hero Dynamic
- Emotional Trauma & Healing
- Intertwined Fates / Secrets from the Past
The Penalty by Lynn Montagano is a gripping sports romance with real emotional meat beneath the glittering veneer of celebrity. Xavier Maddox is England’s star goalkeeper—talented, charismatic, and haunted by past mistakes. Victoria Chase is a woman running from grief, guilt, and a family tragedy she’s never fully confronted.
When their lives collide, the chemistry ignites fast, but the emotional stakes run much deeper than lust or fame. Montagano does a solid job of weaving in the sports-celebrity setting without letting it overshadow the emotional core: the tension between Xavier’s yearning to protect and Victoria’s stubborn drive to stay distant shapes much of the conflict.
Victoria’s guilt and secret history give the story weight, while Xavier’s attempts to break down her walls feel earnest and sometimes desperate, which adds credibility to his gruff-but-caring persona. Their romance isn’t a fairy tale—it’s messy, marked by hesitation, misunderstandings, and the struggle to balance public pressure with private pain.
If there’s a critique, it’s that at times the pacing swings between frenetic (“must resolve secrets now!”) and reflective (“wait, let’s unpack this trauma slowly”), which can tug at the emotional flow. Still, the dialogue feels real, the character motivations hold up, and the romance lands as satisfying. It’s not a soft or easy ride—but if you’re in the mood for a sports romance that leans into heartache, healing, and hard-won happiness, The Penalty delivers.
View all my reviews
No comments:
Post a Comment