Review: Night's Illusion

Night's Illusion by Amanda Ashley
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Night’s Illusion offers an intriguing twist on the vampire romance genre, following Giovanni Lanzoni—a centuries-old vampire who’s also a former priest and, surprisingly, still a virgin. When he rescues Cassie Douglas, a young woman trying to escape a troubled past, the two form a slow, tentative bond that gradually turns into something more.

What I Liked:

• The premise is unique. Giovanni’s vow of celibacy adds emotional complexity and a different kind of tension than the usual brooding alpha vamp.

• Cassie is relatable in her cautious optimism. Their relationship feels tender and respectful, which is a refreshing change from more aggressive romance dynamics.

• The supernatural side characters add warmth and a sense of found family that fans of the series will appreciate.

Where It Fell Short:

• The chemistry between the leads didn’t always land. Their romance sometimes felt more told than shown, making their connection feel a bit flat.

• The villain—Giovanni’s sire—started strong but fizzled quickly, with motivations that felt a little cliché and underdeveloped.

• For a vampire romance, it was surprisingly tame. The “fade to black” approach might work for some, but readers expecting passion and steam may find it lacking.

Final Thoughts:
This book had potential with its thoughtful themes and gentle romance, but it never fully delivered on the emotional or supernatural intensity I was hoping for. It’s a decent entry in the series, but not one that left a lasting impression.

Rating: 3 stars. A sweet and quiet vampire tale that might appeal more to readers looking for subtle romance than sizzling sparks.

View all my reviews